Official RankingsNew York

Top 10 Real Estate Agents in Middletown, New York (May 2026)

The highest-ranked agents in Middletown based on verified sales performance, client reviews, and market expertise.

$310,000

Median Home Price

Avg Days on Market

28848

Population

+4.9%

YoY Price Change

Tracie ChernowskiFeatured

Keller Williams Hudson Valley United

4.9 (29)

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Brian Caplicki

Keller Williams Hudson Valley United

4.9 (29)

875

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Laurel Lustgarten

HOWARD HANNA | RAND REALTY

5.0 (167)

442

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

John J Lease REALTORS

John J. Lease Realtors, Inc.

5.0 (149)

1,824

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Susan C Giordano

John J Lease REALTORS

5.0 (114)

415

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Dominick Tufano

REMAX Benchmark Realty Group

5.0 (120)

617

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Hudson Valley Home Connection

Hudson Valley Home Connection, LLC

5.0 (176)

895

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Christopher Ogden - REALTOR

Realty Promotions, Inc.

5.0 (91)

1,102

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Edwin Rodriguez - Sales

Keller Williams Realty HVU

5.0 (42)

300

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Middletown Real Estate Market

Middletown serves as the commercial hub of Orange County's western region, with a median home price around $310,000. The city offers commuter access to NYC via NJ Transit and Coach USA, attracting buyers seeking affordable alternatives to closer-in Hudson Valley communities.

Homes average 32 days on market. Legoland New York in nearby Goshen and the expanding healthcare corridor at Garnet Health provide local economic drivers. A Middletown agent helps buyers find value in this growing Orange County market.