10
Top10REAgents
Official RankingsOklahoma

Top 10 Real Estate Agents in Stillwater, Oklahoma (April 2026)

The highest-ranked agents in Stillwater based on verified sales performance, client reviews, and market expertise.

$218,600

Median Home Price

31

Avg Days on Market

50800

Population

+4.0%

YoY Price Change

1
T
Ted Newlin

Ted Newlin Realty

5.0 (115)
2
C
Claudette Thornton

One Broker Place

5.0 (92)
3
D
Dolores Lemon

Delores Lemon and Associates

5.0 (70)
4
J
Jason Utley

One Broker Place

5.0 (70)
5
C
Cheryl Carpenter Martin Team

ARC REALTY OK

5.0 (50)
6
R
Rhonda Plake

Rhonda Plake Brokered by Epique Realty

5.0 (69)
7
S
Shanna Grunewald

NextHome Heartland Realty

4.9 (45)
8
B
Bettye Dickey

Realty ONE Group Champion

5.0 (32)
9
K
Karin Biros Stillwater OK

eXp Realty

5.0 (38)
10
A
Ann Morgan

Real Estate Professionals

5.0 (33)

Stillwater's real estate market revolves around Oklahoma State University, creating a dynamic environment where investor-owned rental properties and owner-occupied homes coexist in a tightly supplied market. Rental demand is perennial and strong, with properties near campus generating attractive yields that draw investors from across the state.

Beyond the campus zone, Stillwater's west and south sides offer family-friendly neighborhoods with newer construction and competitive pricing. The city's small-town feel, combined with Big 12 athletics and a vibrant dining scene, makes it appealing to both investors and owner-occupants.

Other Cities in Oklahoma

Explore top-rated real estate agents in other Oklahoma cities.