Official RankingsPennsylvania

Top 10 Real Estate Agents in Erie, Pennsylvania (April 2026)

The highest-ranked agents in Erie based on verified sales performance, client reviews, and market expertise.

$168,200

Median Home Price

Avg Days on Market

94800

Population

+5.8%

YoY Price Change

TRY AGRESTI

AGRESTI REAL ESTATE

5.0 (1028)

5,947

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Coldwell Banker Select - Erie

Coldwell Banker Select

5.0 (527)

7,647

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Joseph Herbert

Joe Herbert Realty

5.0 (258)

Marsha Marsh Real Estate Service

Marsha Marsh RES

5.0 (219)

Stacey Santos

Re/Max Real Estate Group

5.0 (129)

Jake Scheloske

Agresti Real Estate

5.0 (126)

1,581

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Jennifer Nelson

Coldwell Banker Select, REALTORS

5.0 (144)

737

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

RE/MAX Real Estate Group

5.0 (182)

3,005

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Eric Hammill

Agresti Real Estate

5.0 (143)

Steven Szumigale

Remax Real Estate Group

4.9 (93)

493

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Erie offers waterfront living on Lake Erie at prices that represent some of the best value in the Northeast, with median home prices well below $200,000. The city's Bayfront district has seen meaningful investment that has begun to shift perceptions and attract buyers who previously overlooked this Great Lakes city.

The housing market features a diverse range of options, from stately Victorian homes in the Millcreek area to affordable starter homes throughout the city. Healthcare, insurance, and manufacturing anchor the local economy, while Presque Isle State Park provides a recreational amenity that rivals any coastal destination.