10
Top10REAgents
Official RankingsWisconsin

Top 10 Real Estate Agents in New Berlin, Wisconsin (April 2026)

The highest-ranked agents in New Berlin based on verified sales performance, client reviews, and market expertise.

$365,000

Median Home Price

22

Avg Days on Market

40000

Population

5.9

YoY Price Change

1
M
Michael Borowski

Homestead Realty Inc.

5.0 (1078)
2
J
Jeremy Rynders

LET'S GO! Realty Group with Keller Williams Realty

5.0 (227)
3
J
James Geracie

Realty Executives Integrity

4.9 (211)
4
S
Scott Klaas

Keller Williams Realty- Milwaukee Southwest

5.0 (131)
5
J
Jay and Sara Baumgartner

Keller Williams

5.0 (187)
6
J
Justin Hoffmann

Re/Max Lakeside

5.0 (485)
7
T
Tom Sauer

Lake Country Flat Fee

4.9 (111)
8
A
Andrew Uhl

RE/MAX LIBERTY

4.9 (93)
9
M
M3 Realty

M3 Realty

5.0 (168)
10
J
Jodi Olson

Realty Executives

5.0 (191)

New Berlin is a sought-after western Milwaukee suburb that blends suburban convenience with a semi-rural feel. The city's Eisenhower and New Berlin West school districts are well-regarded, and proximity to I-43 and I-894 provides efficient commuter access. The mix of established neighborhoods and preserved green spaces appeals to families seeking a quieter lifestyle without sacrificing metro connectivity.

The housing market features predominantly single-family homes on larger lots, with prices above the Milwaukee average reflecting the area's desirability. Turnover is modest as residents tend to stay long-term, making new listings events that generate quick buyer interest. Agents with AI-driven early listing alerts provide clients a meaningful advantage in this competitive suburban market.

Other Cities in Wisconsin

Explore top-rated real estate agents in other Wisconsin cities.