10
Top10REAgents
Official RankingsNew York

Top 10 Real Estate Agents in Ithaca, New York (April 2026)

The highest-ranked agents in Ithaca based on verified sales performance, client reviews, and market expertise.

$310,000

Median Home Price

30

Avg Days on Market

32872

Population

+3.5%

YoY Price Change

1
C
Claudia Lagalla

Howard Hanna Real Estate

5.0 (289)
2
K
Kathleen Seaman - NY Licensed Assoc. R.E. Broker

Warren Real Estate of Ithaca NY

5.0 (307)
3
J
Jolene Rightmyer Macolini

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty

5.0 (205)
4
K
Karen Hollands

Howard Hanna

5.0 (160)
5
J
Jill Burlington - NY Licensed Assoc. R.E. Broker

Jill Burlington Associate Broker 607-592-0474

5.0 (114)
6
J
Jordan Jacobsen

Warren Real Estate

5.0 (101)
7
M
Melissa Shames

Howard Hanna

4.9 (102)
8
H
Hilda M Moleski

Warren Real Estate

5.0 (101)
9
K
Kyle Gebhart

Warren Real Estate

5.0 (139)
10
S
Steve Saggese - NY Licensed Assoc. R.E. Broker

Warren Real Estate of Ithaca

5.0 (68)

Ithaca Real Estate Market

Ithaca's unique market is shaped by Cornell University and Ithaca College, creating high demand relative to limited supply. The median home price of approximately $310,000 is elevated for upstate New York, reflecting the academic community's purchasing power and the area's stunning Finger Lakes gorge setting.

Homes average 30 days on market, with properties in Fall Creek, Cayuga Heights, and near the Commons moving fastest. The combination of limited buildable land and institutional demand keeps prices firm. An Ithaca agent understands the seasonal market rhythms tied to academic calendars.

Other Cities in New York

Explore top-rated real estate agents in other New York cities.